Whether you’ve received a windfall or you’ve simply built up a sum of money from your regular income, it isn’t always easy to know what to do with it. Saving and investing can seem to pull you in different directions, one feels safe, the other feels like a risk. So which is the right choice?
The honest answer is that the question itself might be the wrong one. Saving and investing aren’t competing options, they’re complementary parts of the same strategy and financial plan. Understanding how they work together is the first step to making your money do more for you.
Savings and investments serve different but equally important roles in a well-rounded financial plan. Savings provide stability, liquidity, and protection against the unexpected. Investments offer the potential to grow your wealth over time. Neither works as well without the other.
Getting the balance right isn’t a one-size-fits-all calculation, it depends on your goals, your timeline, and your financial situation. The five steps below are a practical framework for thinking it through.
The first thing to understand is that leaving money in a current account is not a neutral decision. It’s a slow loss. If your account earns little to no interest and inflation is running at, say, 3% per year, a balance of €100,000 is effectively losing around €3,000 in purchasing power every year, even though the number on your screen stays the same.
According to the Central Bank of Ireland’s Money and Banking Statistics, Irish households hold tens of billions of euros in overnight deposits earning minimal returns. Knowing what inflation is doing to your savings in real terms is the starting point for making better decisions about where your money sits.
Before thinking about growth, think about protection. A financial plan should always include a cash reserve you can access quickly, and most financial planners recommend setting aside at least three to six months’ worth of living expenses in an easily accessible account.
This is your emergency fund, and it should be kept separate from money you’re saving for a specific goal or looking to invest.
A credit union account or An Post savings account can be a good home for your emergency fund. Both are accessible when you need them, but removed enough from your day-to-day banking to stay out of sight and out of mind, which makes it far less tempting to dip into your fund for non-emergencies.
Alongside your emergency fund, consider any significant planned purchases in the next one to five years: a wedding, a home deposit, a car, a holiday or clearing a debt if you’ve come into a lump sum.
Money earmarked for these purposes should also be kept in accessible savings, not tied up in investments where an early exit could cost you. The key principle: if you might need it soon, keep it somewhere you can reach it.
Once your emergency fund and planned purchase money are set aside, any remaining savings can start working harder. There are a number of lower-risk options in Ireland worth considering:
For money you won’t need for at least five years, investing offers the potential for significantly better returns than any savings account. The stock market involves more risk than a deposit account, returns aren’t guaranteed and the value of investments can go down as well as up, but for long-term wealth growth, it has historically outpaced inflation and savings rates.
Managed funds are often a practical starting point for people new to investing, as they spread your money across a range of assets, reducing the impact of any single investment performing poorly. The key is to be honest about your time horizon and your risk appetite before committing.
The table below compares the key features of saving versus investing to help you think through which fits different parts of your financial plan:
Saving |
Investing |
|
Quick access to cash A savings or deposit account gives you access to your money when you need it, though some accounts may limit withdrawals.
|
Typically used for long-term objectives Investing is best suited to medium to long-term goals like funding a child’s education or retirement. Access during the investment period may be subject to charges or penalties.
|
|
Minimal risk involved Money in a savings account is protected under the Deposit Guarantee Scheme, subject to certain limits.
|
Delayed access to funds Invested money may be tied up for a specific period or require more time to access than a savings account.
|
|
Earns interest Savings accounts pay interest, though returns are typically lower than investment options.
|
Always carries risk There is no guarantee of returns and there is a possibility of losing some or all of your invested capital.
|
| Low potential returns
Even at competitive rates, deposit returns are generally lower than investment returns over the long term.
|
Potential for higher earnings Investments offer the opportunity to grow your wealth at a rate that savings accounts typically cannot match over time.
|
There’s no universal formula for how much you should save versus invest, the right split depends on your income, your outgoings, your goals and how comfortable you are with risk. A qualified financial advisor can help you work through all of this and put a plan in place that fits your actual circumstances.
At askpaul, our financial planning consultations are designed to help you get a clear picture of where you stand and what to do next. Whether you’re looking to build a savings strategy that beats inflation or you’re ready to explore investment options for long-term growth, the first conversation is free.
Find out more about our Services
Have a question? You can always askpaul!